facebook rss twitter

Review: Apple Mac mini - Core Duo

by Tarinder Sandhu on 22 June 2006, 02:35

Tags: Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qafym

Add to My Vault: x

Final thoughts, awards and HEXUS.right2reply


At a glance

Pros

* Astonishingly small - taking up less desktop real estate than a typical mouse mat - and easily portable
* Uses Intel dual-core CPU - delivering more than enough power for most digital home uses
* Perfectly usable as a Windows XP PC - and XP can be easily installed with help from Apple's Boot Camp utility
* Good looking, well designed and well built
* Easy to get up and running out of the box
* Runs very cool, runs very quietly - although you can hear the CPU fan when it does occasionally kick in (and DVD activity, too)
* Good built-in networking & wireless connectivity - Gigabit, fast wireless and Bluetooth are standard
* Powerful and easy-to-use bundled software, especially the established programs in the iLife suite
* Installing software and new hardware has probably never been easier than it is under OS X
* Some cute OS interface features that make it easy to switch between different apps and windows
* Widgets - pop-up applets that make life easier
* Not hard to access shared folders on Windows local networks (and Windows users can access shared folders on the mini)


Not strictly a Mac mini thing but it impressed us...

* Seamless integration between Elgato's eyetv 2 software and Roxio's Toast 7 DVD burning software (neither included with the mini, though)

Cons

* Program and folder windows can only be manually resized by clicking and dragging the RH bottom corner - it's madness
* Opening the case to upgrade RAM, hard disk or CPU is not a simple job (but nor is it impossible)
* No TV tuner support in Apple's Front Row media front end, so the mini can't genuinely replace a conventional Windows MCE PC when running OS X (the mini might still make a great media centre PC if it can run Windows XP MCE 2005 - something we were unable to test)
* Amount of RAM fitted as standard needs to be increased to 1GB
* The hard drive fitted as standard should be of bigger capacity
* Worryingly, some tasks in iTunes and QT Pro take longer under OS X than under XP - Apple needs to sort this out on the hurry up
* Some big-name programs still not available in versions that run natively under OS X on Intel Macs (perhaps this will change after the WWDC in August?)
* OS X user interface (and programs running under it) don't look as sharp and distinct as XP's GUI and programs running under it
* Only one audio output and one audio input - so speakers and headphones, for instance, can't be connected simultaneous without using a two-way adaptor
* Better support needed for good quality printing to printers attached to Windows networked PCs
* Do external power supplies really need to be that big?
* Apple itself not yet offering to install Windows XP for you (some clued up dealers are, though)
* Still a little pricey, despite recent price cuts - too many of us are unwilling to pay extra for quality, so Apple may need to make further reductions
* Apple's Mighty Mouse isn't. Mighty, that is. Opt for something better and cheaper, don't swallow the hype (but make sure it has at least five buttons)



We lusted after an Intel Mac mini long before we ever got one into our clutches and now that our affair is over, we're feeling lonely.

Okay, that's a bit maudlin - and we're not actually such sados. What we really mean is that nothing during our time with the mini made us change our minds about what a very neat and desirable piece of kit it is - quite the opposite - even though we do now know for sure that it's not perfect.

We'd be happy recommending this Intel-powered Mac mini to any friend or relative and to HEXUS readers, too, except those who are potential power users or big-time games players. For most people, though, a mini could be the perfect choice - irrespective of what operating system they wish to run (apart from Unix). It's an easy-to-use, high-quality personal computer that takes up next to no room, works quietly and gives off no significant amount of heat.

An Apple mini is, we believe, a far better option for most people than a laptop - the choice that many people now make not because they're road warriors but simply to avoid having a big system box cluttering up the house.

If you are seriously tempted, go for it, you know you want one!


HEXUS.award












Thoughts on this review? Share them with us over in the HEXUS.community.

HEXUS.links

HEXUS.community - discussion thread about this article
HEXUS.review - Apple Boot Camp Public Beta (by HEXUS.community stalwart Gordy)
HEXUS.headline - WinXP and Mac OS X can dual-boot on Intel Macs!
HEXUS.headline - Apple set to announce Conroe plans on August 7?
Unofficial dual-boot compo - home page
Apple - Boot Camp Public Beta home page
Apple UK - Mac mini home page
Apple UK - mini's specs page
Apple UK - Dashboard (the widgets app)
Apple UK - Exposé
Apple UK store - home page
Apple UK - home page
Apple - Rosetta home page (not a lot of use!)
Wikipedia - Apple's Rosetta Technology (a lot more useful!)
Parallels - Parallels Desktop for Mac home page
Elgato - eyetv for DTT home page
Elgato - eyetv 2 home page
Elgato - home page
Miglia UK - TVMini home page
Miglia UK - home page
Roxio UK - Toast 7 home page
Amazon UK - Toast 7 buying page

WMV videos in this review

Apple Front Row in action (4.91MB)
Elgato eyetv 2 in action (1.84MB)
Parallels Desktop for Mac in action (4MB)

AVI videos from Gordy's Boot Camp Beta review

Windows XP booting (1.8MB)
Counter Strike being played - 01 (11.3MB)
Counter Strike being played - 02 (9.1MB)
Counter Strike stress-test running (5.1MB)
Is that a Dell I see before me? (6.3MB)
Battlefield 2 being played - 01 (4.6MB)
Battlefield 2 being played - 02 (5.1MB)

HEXUS Right2Reply

At HEXUS, we invite the companies whose products we test to comment on our articles. If Apple's representatives choose to do so, we'll publish their commentary here verbatim.


HEXUS Forums :: 11 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
I have to say I love the Mac Mini.. But whether I could spend so much on one is another matter.

Great review though guys, thorough and interesting!
Deviate
Great review though guys, thorough and interesting!


:embarrassed:
Good review!

For me the mac mini is a great design but you're definitely paying a premium for a computer thats not really a media centre and is an expensive, but average performing computer once you've bought all the bits.

Having actually used the basic mac mini with no upgrades for a brief period i can say you definitely want the core duo and 1GB ram as standard. For media centre use you'd also want a larger hdd. Once you've then added the keyboard and mighty mouse combo you're looking at a total price of £693 before you've even added a TV tuner. For that sort of money you can build a decent HTPC that IMO is more suited to the ‘media centre’ job.

If you're not using the mini as a media centre but as a computer instead then you would also need to factor in the cost of a monitor (£200) so then the total would increase to £893. It's at this point IMO its worth getting the Macbook instead (what i did). Not only is the Macbook faster, the added portability is a massive bonus.
Anyone have details on where you can find out how to install MCE 2005 on a mac mini?
answered my own question!

found this on another forum

Here's a quick how to install Windows MCE OEM 2005 using Bootcamp…

1) Attach a external CD or DVD drive to your computer with disc 2 of MCE 2005 inserted in it, or copy the contents of disc 2 MCE 2005 to a external USB drive. Might work with a firewire drive too.

2) Follow Apples Boot Camp instuctions to install XP.

3) During the XP install process when it asks for disc 2, hit OK, and change the path to your external drive. In my case I just changed the drive letter to D: . Note if you try to browse to the external drive it will not be seen but if you just change the path it works.

Thats it, complete the install and install Boot camp drivers, in my case I ended up with a Mac Mini running MCE, which I think is just perfect for using as a media center.

If you have the MCE remote and sensor they work just fine too.

JayMak

Bob Crabtree adds - just for the record, this came from the Macrumors forum.