facebook rss twitter

Review: NVIDIA GeForce GTS 450 vs. GTX 550 Ti at same clocks

by Tarinder Sandhu on 18 March 2011, 08:37

Tags: NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qa45y

Add to My Vault: x

Final thoughts

NVIDIA has too many GPUs vying for space in a congested market. Look to spend £90-£130 - yeah, pretty arbitrary, we know - on your next graphics-card upgrade and just on NVIDIA's side you can plump for a GeForce GTS 450; GTX 460 768MB; GTX 460 1GB and, now, a GTX 550 Ti: phewee.

Making sense of it all, GTX 460 1GB is the standout card of the bunch, offering an excellent performance-per-pound metric. Go right down and the GTS 450 1GB isn't a bad bet, if you can find one cheap enough. Stuck in the middle is the all-new GTX 550 Ti, and pricing is such that it really is in no-man's land.

But what if you already have a GTS 450 1GB and wonder if a quick trip to the Bay of Fleas is in order, supplanting it with the GTX 550 Ti? Our advice would be that it's not, curbed by the knowledge of how stock-clock cards perform. Ratchet up the GTS 450 to the same clocks as a GTX 550 Ti and, going by the numbers in this examination, the 550 Ti becomes an even harder sell.

Being even-handed, most GTX 550 Ti arrive in pre-overclocked form, thereby widening the gap between GPUs, but this article reinforces the notion that price, not technical prowess, is what's holding NVIDIA's latest GPU back. What's more, AMD's significant performance gains with Catalyst 11.4 drivers mean that it's hard to overlook the 17-month-old Radeon HD 5770 1GB card.

NVIDIA will undoubtedly shift a large number of GeForce GTX 550 Ti cards, with most populating mid-range PCs from large-capacity system builders. Enthusiasts, though, will do well to steer clear until the price drops below the magical £100,



HEXUS Forums :: 12 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Well it's pretty much what I expected, the nvidia 5xx series is just the 4xx series as it should of been if nvidia had been ontop of the fab process.
After massive delays they had to get something out so we got the 4xx series, now they got the issues sorted we get a new series which can more reliably clock higher and don't have blocks masked off.
I'm guessing nvidia still has a lot of 4xx chips left they have to shift which is why they have to keep the prices up above the 4xx series cards.
Worth updating from an 8800gt?

Seriously. These things should go back to the last couple of major step releases.

Otherwise, with nVidia apparently releasing cards at a geometric rate (Yesterday: 460! Midnight just gone: 470.5! This morning: 522.456! Lunchtime: 620! (actually a downgrade on the 420.57revb!) This time tomorrow: the AFD520GTXXX), and apparently using Deep Blue-equivalent Prime Number crunchers to regulate the logic behind their numbering sequences, people like me are losing touch.

Does the damn thing play Crysis yet?
Interesting….. It begs some questions!

What is the point of reference for this card? How does it compare vs the higher and lower end cards?

I can't help feel that this is half a story. A higher end comparison would allow someone to compare vs other games meaningfully. i.e. if it shows that it's 45% as many FPS in Metro 2033, then it gives you indicative numbers for, say Crysis which isn't included in the numbers.

Likewise, please can you give an “upgrading from” comparison? A 1950 or 3850 or 4850 from AMD and an 8800 GT would be reasonable as these are likely upgrade candidates. In the review you are considering the alternatives in Market, but completely ignoring the reference point people have. Tomshardware do this very well, but Hexus don't.

PLEASE will someone do some folding metrics. I'm getting to sound like a stuck record, but there are uses for these thing other than games, and there's a significant community here at Hexus involved in that scene. Is there a reason that these requests have gone unanswered for so long?
I have an HD4830 myself and I wouldn't get an HD5770 1GB or GTX550TI 1GB as the upgrade is not that big IMHO. The HD5770 1GB is around the same speed as an HD4870 in most games.

I would consider a GTX460,HD6850 or HD5850 as better upgrades.
It would be nice to have some folding details on these reviews.

I was recently in the market for a sub £200 card. Torn between a 560 and a 6950. But, although I game, that is not the only use the PC gets. I also fold.

I know a lot of people don't fold, but a lot of people don't play Metro 2033 either.