facebook rss twitter

Review: Lord of the NAS: QNAP Turbo Station TS-109 Pro

by Steve Kerrison on 23 July 2007, 08:55

Tags: Qnap

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qajea

Add to My Vault: x

Conclusions, where2buy, certifications, awards, right2reply

Conclusions, where2buy, certifications, awards, right2reply

So here we are, at the final shakedown. If had to use just one word to describe the TS-109 Pro, it would be "impressive".

It's impressive because QNAP has managed to pack a lot of features onto the device and provide easy access for savvy users to add even more if they want to.

There are also enough features as standard to keep almost everyone else happy.

Dig a little deeper and there are some issues. We didn't like the misalignment between the hard drive and the SATA connectors - installing a drive made us nervous and that's a bad thing.

We hope that this problem was a one-off but can't say for sure. Perhaps QNAP will clarify the situation by having its say in HEXUS Right2Reply.

The fact that the TS-109 Pro is a passively-cooled NAS box also made us a little nervous - hard drives hate heat.

We don't like noisy little fans either but we'd rather find a way of dampening fan-noise than dealing with the huge turmoil of prematurely losing a hard drive.

The aluminium casing of the TS-109 doesn't come into direct contact with the internal hard disk. If it did, the drive would probably stay a lot cooler and we'd definitely be a lot happier.

And a fan isn't necessarily a magic solution. Despite having one, the Thecus N1200 doesn't seem to provide any better cooling. Its external temperature during disk usage is much the same as the TS-109 - at around 45C.

Overall, the TS-109's performance was good. Sometimes it was a little slower than Thecus N1200, sometimes a bit quicker.

Sometimes - but not very often - it could even out-pace a multi-disk NAS device. And that is impressive!

Assuming that the feature-set of the TS-109 Pro suits your needs, it should be able to deliver all the performance you want.

We liked being able to back up the TS-109 onto an external disk - and QNAP's elegant options for providing that extra data security. This, after all, is a single-drive NAS box and, as you'll appreciate, it's unwise to keep all your eggs in one basket.

Adding PHP/MySQL to the mix is an interesting twist. We doubt that it's suitable for any real production web sites but it might be handy for hosting some locally-served web-based tools.

So, should you buy a TS-109 Pro? That's a tough one to answer.

We love the features, including how open the platform is for those who want to tweak it a bit.

We like that it's quiet but low-noise wouldn't be one of our major concerns when choosing such a product.

What about the price? Well, an SRP of £170 - and it's ~£150 for the non-Pro version - means that that the TS-109 is a little more expensive than some of its competitors but level with the rest.

Bottom line? If you want a NAS box and a single-disk solution is appropriate to your home or small-business needs, then the QNAP TS-109 Pro is definitely worth adding to your shortlist.

HEXUS Certifications

The QNAP TS-109 Pro passed testing in the HEXUS Labs, so we can stamp it with a HEXUS Certification in the Executive category to affirm that it's suitable for use in the small office.

HEXUS Labs - Executive Certification

HEXUS Awards

Sensible pricing, good performance and an attractive features-set - including useful multimedia functionality - mean that the TS-109 merits a HEXUS Media Recommended award.

HEXUS Labs - Media :: Recommended

HEXUS Where2Buy

The TS-109 series will be available from Miniland-Tech and various other online retailers in the UK, including SCAN, Amazon, Qnap.co.uk, Ripcaster and XSPO.

HEXUS Right2Reply

At HEXUS.net, we invite the companies whose products we test to comment on our articles. If any of QNAP's representatives choose to respond, we'll publish their commentary here verbatim.

HEXUS related reading

HEXUS.net - Mass storage – all news and reviews
HEXUS.net - reviews :: Thecus N1200 NAS Media Server
HEXUS.net - reviews :: Thecus 1U4500S 1U rack-mount NAS
HEXUS.net - reviews :: Thecus N1200 RouStor NAS - first look
HEXUS.net - reviews :: Thecus N5200 NAS appliance - 3.5 terabytes tested



HEXUS Forums :: 5 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
I am pleased NAS is becoming more mainstream :) I am keen though, for someone to add some sort of backup software which makes life easier for the mainstream user
I think one of the most important points you've missed in this review is that TwonkyMedia's UPNP streaming is second to none. Its is probably the best solution for streaming to an Xbox 360 without the need of a PC.

I have a Synology 106J and have just registered a copy of it which I have manually installed onto it and it servers all my home media devices, but more importantly my 360 and I believe it now supports PS3's as well

If the OS is unlocked installing something like MLDonkey on it as well will make your download life a breeze as well
Good review Tarinder - confirmed to me that I should get one!

My LAN is only 100Mb so for the moment it has not reached its full potential. One thing I dont understand / need help with…

If I attach a USB drive directly to QNAP and want to transfer files from it (using the Qmultimedia web interface), I select the drive using the browse function (its shown as a network drive). All the data goes from the USB drive to my PC and back to QNAP instead of by a direct transfer. Very slow. This is either madness or there must be another way to transfer files from attached USB Hard drive. (The copy button is not suitable)

Any comments appreciated.

PS. I just tried to cut and paste a file between QUSB folder and Qmultimedia folder and the file is tranferred via the LAN! (even using WEB multimedia upload interface). This cant be right. Pls help.
You're initiating the transfers from your machine, which means they'll go through your machine.

Basically you can't do it the way you're trying.

Probably your best option is to SSH into the box, work out what directories the Qmultimedia and USB drive reside in, then issue the copy command via that. That way it'll run from the TS-109 itself :)
Hi Steve, Thanks very much. That is exactly what I want to do. I tried using the web interface (web file manager) and got no-where and dont know how to SSH. Can you be more specific. The web file manager for me would be the easiest if it can.

BTW I pressed the “copy USB” button yesterday. It was soooo slow. There is no 480Mbs about it. 8GBs took over an hour. I thought it would save time being faster than my 100Mbs LAN. It wasnt. I then had to transfer it into another folder (externally) and that took another age and defeated the whole object.

Considering the set up is so straight forward I really think this “problem” should get some mention somewhere.

Apart from the hours getting stuff on the disk, I do really like it!

Thanks in advance Steve (or any other knowledgeable sole).