facebook rss twitter

Review: Thecus YES Box N2100

by Steve Kerrison on 19 January 2006, 09:37

Tags: Thecus (4978.TWO)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qaehw

Add to My Vault: x

Thoughts, HEXUS.awards & HEXUS.right2reply

Thecus' YES Box N2100 does a lot of things right. It's robust, despite its plastic exterior; it looks good, but keep your grubby hands off; it's easy to setup, both hardware and software; it's easy to use, with multiple ways of getting at your data; and it's fast enough to serve multiple users simultaneously, but a little more performance wouldn't go amiss.

The YES Box borrows some nice features from its bigger N4100 brother, including its RAID support, e-mail and buzzer notification, user permissions and admin interface. Weighing in at around £260, it works out at about half the price of the N4100. For that price, however, hard drives are not included. Pop a couple of 300GB drives inside and you're looking at a total cost nearer the £400 mark.

So, do we say 'yes' to the YES Box? Yes, yes we do, providing that it meets your needs, and that's the case with all products isn't it? It's a network attached storage device that you can setup in a jiffy, then practically forget about. It'll just sit there, serving your files, taking your backups, copying your USB sticks, sharing your iTunes library, without any problems. We like it, and like it a lot. Definitely one for those looking for somewhere to put all that media for their digital home.

Media - Recommended
Thecus YES Box N2100

HEXUS Right2Reply

HEXUS World Leading HEXUS Right2Reply initiative invites manufacturers, their representatives and vendors which supply HEXUS with products for technical editorial evaluation, to comment on the articles that we publish. Thecus has provided us with the following response:

First of all, Thecus would like to thank Hexus for another in depth review of Thecus products. A feedback from a renowned media like Hexus means a lot to Thecus.

Thecus envisioned YES Box, N2100 , to be the digital home media storage center. We are making every effort toward this goal and making sure consumers are actually enjoying digital life.

At Thecus, we listen to our customers. We will try to make the product as perfect as possible. Through firmware upgrades, YES Box will get more features and more speed. We would love everyone to start enjoying the YES Box.

H. C. Yen
PM Director

HEXUS Where2Buy

The YES Box N2100 is available from the following locations:

USA:
ASI
Newegg
AMAX.

UK:
Boston Ltd.
SCAN
Origin Storage Ltd.
Morex.



HEXUS Forums :: 23 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
It sounds to me like its performance is just as poor as the N4100 :(

I've been using an N4100 now on and off for around 6 months, I say ‘on and off’ as until a recent firmware update it would constantly vanish from from the network.

What Thecus is doing is commendable, however, the performace is just downright crap. As an exmaple I transfered 500MB's worth of data from a Dell PowerEdge 2800 server running Windows Server 2003 to my N4100 and it took approx 4 minutes, from the above server to another Dell 2800 the transfer took 40 seconds.

The CPU used in these devices by Thecus is woefully underpowered :(
Fatboy40
It sounds to me like its performance is just as poor as the N4100 :(

I've been using an N4100 now on and off for around 6 months, I say ‘on and off’ as until a recent firmware update it would constantly vanish from from the network.

What Thecus is doing is commendable, however, the performace is just downright crap. As an exmaple I transfered 500MB's worth of data from a Dell PowerEdge 2800 server running Windows Server 2003 to my N4100 and it took approx 4 minutes, from the above server to another Dell 2800 the transfer took 40 seconds.

The CPU used in these devices by Thecus is woefully underpowered :(
Indeed it is the CPU, it's quite a general purpose one but I do believe you can find it in PDAs. I reckon Thecus should think about moving to a nano-ITX form factor and an appropriate VIA chip, as that would surely deliver much better throughput.
Great review of the Thecus N2100!

It does seem like the CPU is limiting transfer speeds. In this review, write speeds reached around 5-6 MB/sec, and CPU usage seemed to peg close to 100%. An ExtremeTech review of the similar N4100 (which has the same Intel XScale IOP 80219 processor) pegged CPU utilization at around 65%, and read/write transfers at around 9-10 MB/sec. FatBoy40's real-world experience seems to suggest a transfer rate of only 2 MB/sec (500 MB in 4 min). You would figure that the ntel 80219 CPU, which I believe is rated at 600 MHz, and its platform which supports 64-bit 133 MHz PCI-X architecture with a 200 MHz bus, would be fast enough. See http://www.intel.com/design/iio/80219.htm

I wonder if there's a way to “benchmark” the different CPUs used in different NAS solutions, like the Buffalo Gigabit Linkstation, etc.

My only question is, how large is that fan, and (1) does it keep the unit cool enough, (2) is it loud? One of the problems others have noted with the Thecus N4100 model is it is very loud.

Thanks!
Hi Tarrant,

The fan is a 40mm model and it's temperature controlled. With the drives we had in the box, it wasn't all that noisy, certainly not as noisy as the N4100 and nowhere near as noisy as the Synology DiskStation 101g+ gets.
Well, after spending hundreds of dollars at Newegg for the Thecus N2100 and a pair of Maxtor Maxline III 300 GB SATA-II drives, I have to say I'm bummed.

Physical installation was easy. But the case was quite flimsy, and was made of thin plastic rather than metal like aluminum. My unit (black) also came with the external side panels already scratched and scuffed.

After installing the pair of hard drives and plugging in the power and LAN cables, I ran their Windows-based setup utility. Here, I had to reconfigure my router, as my local network had an address of 192.168.2.xxx while the N2100 defaulted to a fixed IP address of 192.168.1.100 … had to change my LAN IP to be able to detect the unit.

Next, I found that the firmware was 1.0.3, while the latest available was 1.0.5hotfix1. Updated firmware, rebooted.

I was glad to see that the N2100 was able to detect and correctly identify the make, model, and capacity of my two drives. However, the unit hanged when trying to create the JBOD or RAID volume.

CPU usage during the RAID creation was 100%. However, the RAID Information status screen showed that it was unable to figure out how to complete the build. The N2100 was stuck at “Formating … Please wait … ” … there was no percent-complete indicator, it was unable to tell me the volume capacity, and it was never able to complete the RAID or JBOD configuration step, which meant that the unit was unusable as a NAS.

After trying to reset to factory default settings, fiddling with one-versus-two drives installed, it still failed to initialize the volume (even after waiting 8 hours!) The other thing was, I got this crytic error message from its web-configuration interface while it crashed:

Warning: Division by zero in /img/inc/info/cpuinfo.class.php on line 156

Finally, the unit died on me and now even fails to boot. The status indicator light is blinking red indicating a system error, and I can no longer access the web-based interface. Even the Windows-based setup utility cannot identify the N2100 on the network.

Thecus tech support in the USA was unable to help me, but to their credit they've escalated this issue to their HQ in Taiwan. Unfortunately, they are all celebrating Chinese New Years, and won't be back to their offices until next week. I have a feeling I will have to either (1) RMA the N2100, or (2) swallow the 15% restocking fee at Newegg and get another set of SATA drives. FYI Thecus maintains a very small list of hard drives that have been tested as being “compatible” with the N2100 … many drives are “older” models, such as the Maxtor Maxline II or Seagate Barracuda 7200.7 and 7200.8 series.

In the meantime, I've spend ~$600 for a non-functional product. Definitely not a good customer experience!

Any thoughts or suggestions?