facebook rss twitter

Adblock Plus gets shins kicked by Google "security measures"

by Mark Tyson on 21 February 2013, 11:45

Tags: Google (NASDAQ:GOOG), Chrome, PC

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qabsy5

Add to My Vault: x

Google has made it much more difficult to use the ad-blocking utility Adblock Plus on its latest Android OS and in its desktop Chrome browser. Adblock developers observed recent software changes implemented by Google and made some workarounds utilising automatic proxy server configuration, so that people could still use its ad-blocking utility. Google seems to have reacted to this and made Adblock Plus’s new workarounds on Android much more complicated and manual - in the name of system security. It sounds like this is a high stakes game (advertising revenue) of internet cat and mouse.

Android

The Adblock Plus Android app will no longer work on non-rooted Android 4.1.2 or 4.2.2 devices without going through an eight-stage configuration of a proxy server.

Till Faida, co-founder of the Adblock Plus project told The Register that “We are not opposed to the fix per se. We just think Google shouldn't deliberately break any functionality when fixing something”. Faida went on to say that Adblock coders have raised the issue on Google code forums and hope that the “do no evil” company will help “provide a solution that addresses security concerns and still respects user's choices”.

some of the fiddly manual proxy config stages

Chrome

Google also seems to have taken part in snake-like, body-swerving, goalpost-moving behaviour regarding Adblock Plus running within its Chrome browser. First of all the Adblock Plus extension stopped appearing in searches of web browser extensions/apps available to Chrome users, as the updated search function only looked at “apps”. Then, when Adblock was made into a Chrome app, it was only available for 12 hours before being removed.

Honesty is the best policy

If Google wants to stop the use of Adblock Plus on its platforms on commercial grounds, as it is a major online advertising industry player, it should just come out and say so. I think most people could understand that action and the business motives behind it. Are all these Adblock shenanigans really just about the security of end users?



HEXUS Forums :: 26 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Just ban Adblock outright, and let people use a different browser if they really it.
I've always used AdBlock in Chrome, not the plus/pro or whatever. Works a charm :-)

Here

Confusingly there are similar named extensions by different authors on different browsers not all affiliated with each other.
If they outright block it, a lot of people will move back to Firefox. It was only when Chrome's Adblock Plus got up to parity with the FF version that I fully moved to Chrome as the main browser. For me at least, Adblock/Plus and Ghostery are a dealbreaker on browser choice.
I feel that Google whilst stuck between a rock and a hard place might regret this. I use adblock as it actually improves the browser experience. Ebay for example is a nightmare with the ads (mind you the redesign by a blind man's dog is awful) and is arguably 100 times easier to use on my mobile now. Thus FF is still my main browser as I have slightly more control to my liking…
I wouldnt even use an ad blocker if it wasnt for the ads with sound. Nothing is more annoying than having to go through dozens of tabs just to find where the pause button is on one advert