vacancies advertise contact news tip The Vault
facebook rss twitter

Google must remove piracy keywords from autocomplete

by Mark Tyson on 19 July 2012, 17:33

Tags: Google (NASDAQ:GOOG)

Quick Link:

Add to My Vault: x

The French Supreme Court has ordered that Google should strop promoting online piracy by ceasing to autocomplete terms with words such as ‘torrent’, ‘rapidshare’ and ‘megaupload’. Google instant and autocomplete searches were adding piracy related keywords to searches for popular artists. For instance if you were to input “Rolling Stones 40 Licks” the search engine may suggest within the dropdown list of choices some extended phrases such as “Rolling Stones 40 Licks torrent” or “Rolling Stones 40 Licks rapidshare”.

In our experience in the UK such Google autocomplete suggestions do not appear. We have already had a lack of piracy related suggestions for over a year. Google already blocks these keywords and others from autocomplete of its own volition. Also the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) has requested Google to take down tens of thousands of search links to suspected pirated content. So, again using the above search as an example “Rolling Stones 40 Licks” brings up a first page of ‘kosher’ links, but as soon as the second page the following notices appear at the end of the search results list “In response to a complaint we received under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act, we have removed 2 result(s) from this page. If you wish, you may read the DMCA complaint that caused the removal(s) at”

The French court recognises that Google is not to blame for the infringements taking place on websites it links to. However it says Google is responsible for its suggestions which may promote pirate content, therefore keyword filters are appropriate to reduce online piracy. While the piracy encouraging terms are not suggested by the search engine, Google searches including those terms still work as you would expect. In the case of searching “Rolling Stones 40 Licks torrent” hundreds of pages of torrent links are spewed forth by Google, peppered with a few US DCMA removal notices.

Google will be taking the case to the French Appeals Court to avoid being dictated to about what words should be filtered from its search tools. File sharing news specialist website Torrentfreak puts forward the argument that “We assume that Google is fighting the decision to keep control over what they choose to censor. If the case is decided against them, they can expect more requests for keywords to be added to the filter, or even entire websites.” The search site has already acted in removing what it considers to be “tempting” automatic suggestions for downloadable content searches. Also Google have been working under a huge barrage of search result removal requests by the likes of Microsoft, RIAA members, the BPI and

HEXUS Forums :: 12 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Les Idiots.
The retardation continues!!!
I bet if xxx related words are blocked, xxx industry will be wiped out.
hahaha, against some of the most gifted internet users they block an autocorrect on one search engine!

Not even worth the text it is typed out with!
OK, so using their own example, Bing returns first related search as “Rolling Stones 40 Licks Torrent”, Yahoo and Lycos start displaying results from TPB on the second page of results… the list could go on with examples for pretty much any search engine out there. And all this is OK with this court and only Google is supposed to adhere to another one of these “highly researched” court decisions? Not wanting to overly support Google (how uncool would that be? LOL!), but did these judges ever remove their heads out their behinds or is a colorectal surgery in order? Who knows, they might even like it?