facebook rss twitter

Facebook used to catch looter while Essex police get carried away

by Scott Bicheno on 16 August 2011, 13:30

Tags: Facebook, UK Government

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qa6wk

Add to My Vault: x

Retribution

The first government response to a perceived threat is often to restrict civil liberties and the recent riots/looting were no exception. The PM wasted little time in proposing denying access to social media for naughty people, and today the home secretary is openly considering the introduction of blanket curfews.

A couple of stories flagged up by the beeb show how demonising technology is not only misguided and authoritarian, but will probably do more harm than good.

An information security professional - Greg Martin - blogged last week ‘Why you don't steal from a hacker'. Martin had his MacBook Pro nicked when a looter broke into his flat during the London riots. Fortunately - and you can't buy this kind of PR - he had installed open-source tracking software Prey on his Mac.

Within a couple of days Martin received notification that his Mac had been accessed and the software proceeded to pass on a bunch of info about what the thief was up to, including photos of the baddie himself taken with the webcam, his Facebook profile (including home address), and an account of his online activities. The thief was promptly nicked and the Mac returned.

Meanwhile Essex police appear to have got the memo that BlackBerry Messenger was extensively used by looters to coordinate their efforts. With unquestioning zeal they now seem to have embarked on a crusade against BBM on the apparent assumption it's now used exclusively for riot choreography.

They seem to think they've done well too, and have published a lengthy statement on the Essex police website detailing their many breakthroughs in the war on BBM. The first victory mentioned - clearly one of the highlights - was the arrest of a 20-year-old bloke for using BBM to arrange a water-fight, which is apparently a ‘serious crime'.

 



HEXUS Forums :: 20 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Ya gotta laugh at the government who cracks down on ‘thugs’ by being far greater and insidious thugs, themselves.
I must admit that I don't quite get how a water fight constitutes a crime, let alone a serious one. In that case, the entire coterie of occupants of my old uni flat are obviously hardened crim's, because we used to have water fights with other flats on a periodic basis. They'd ambush us, we'd ambush them. And so on. In-between extended bouts of serious and diligent study, of course. ;) :embarrassed:


But as for BBM, as far am I'm concerned, if you commit a criminal offence by organising or encouraging violence (and you do), then the medium you use is pretty irrelevant. You certainly shouldn't get a free pass just because it's BBM, Twitter or Facebook, etc.

So I'd say it's merely that the police now are catching up with the use of these tools for this kind of thing, and that BBM etc are clearly no longer a safe haven for this type of activity, but rather, will now leave a trail of breadcrumbs and a log of evidence that will likely not only lead police to offenders, but go a long way to securing convictions, too.

As for blanket bans, in the very short term and in response to specific events, like these riots, I'd say turning services off while they're being abused is far enough. Whether this happens as a result of the authorities issuing an order that the companies have to obey, or a request that they choose to, remains to be seen. The latter is fine with me, but the former …. not so sure.
Was this really the best strategy by RIM? because those people are going to get a new a BB
aidanjt
Ya gotta laugh at the government who cracks down on ‘thugs’ by being far greater and insidious thugs, themselves.

I'm not sure that a police officer could be branded a thug because they are trying to contain the lawless behaviour of a sick individual..

I'd happily watch an officer beat a criminal as clearly there own parents haven't had the foresight to do it instead!

Bravo to this man for using technology to gain the upper hand.
Then you wont mind when the government bugs your car and all your other electronic equipment and a cop batons you over the head as soon as you slip up.