facebook rss twitter

Pro-HDTV E-Petition - PM passes buck, says 'tell Ofcom yourself'

by Bob Crabtree on 28 February 2007, 01:52

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qahzd

Add to My Vault: x


10 Downing Street crest

The UK Prime Minister's office emailed us last night (no problemo Tony mate, we guess you were a bit tied up yourself, so we'll give you a bell at the weekend!), saying there is now a response online to a recent E-Petition we signed. This was a demand that, after the analogue switchover, Ofcom should allocate the unused radio spectrum to HDTV services.

The PM's response says that this decision is a matter for Ofcom itself and advises petitioners - 4,904 people signed up - to respond directly to the regulator's current consultation about the switchover, which ends next month (on March 20).

So not a lot of joy there!

This is what the email says,

Government response to petition 'openhdtv'

You recently signed a petition asking the Prime Minister to "force Ofcom to allocate the unused radio spectrum after the analogue switchover to HDTV services."

The Prime Minister's Office has responded to that petition and you can view it here:
http://www.number-10.gov.uk/output/Page11103.asp

Prime Minister's Office

Petition info: http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/openhdtv/


The response page says,

Openhdtv - epetition reply

27 February 2007

We received a petition asking:

"We the undersigned petition the Prime Minister to force Ofcom to allocate the unused radio spectrum after the analogue switchover to HDTV services."

Details of petition:

"In 2012, analogue television services will be switched off. It is likely that Ofcom (the regulator) will sell the radio frequencies (parts of the radio spectrum) that the analogue channels used to mobile phone companies. We believe that Britain still needs to be the world leader in broadcasting. As a result of allocating these frequencies to HDTV (High-definition television) broadcasts we think that Britain can continue to lead the world in television in the same way that John Logie Baird did in the 1930s. Countries such as America and Australia are already rolling out this technology but Britain has been left behind because of the lack of spectrum space."

Read the petition

Petitions home page


Read the Government's response

The Government recognises that HD is one of many applications that could utilise spectrum released by Digital Switchover.

Like Ofcom, the Government believes that technology-neutral auctions offer the most effective way of allocating spectrum. However, we also accept Ofcom's view that some applications generate benefits for society, and that it is vital that these benefits continue to be captured in a world where spectrum if a flexible, market-based resource.

Spectrum management is now a matter for Ofcom, the independent regulator of the communications sector. On 19 December, Ofcom issued a consultation document on the Digital Dividend Review (which is concerned with the allocation of spectrum released by Digital Switchover). The consultation ends on 20 March 2007 and the Government looks forward to the developing debate the consultation has generated.

Given that the consultation is still in progress, we would advise the petitioners to respond to the above consultation, at http://www.ofcom.org.uk/consult/condocs/ddr/ in order to register their views. Additionally, Ofcom's contact details are at http://www.ofcom.org.uk/contactus/.


Got a take on the HDTV E-Petition and E-Petitions in general as an exercise in democracy? Are they a total waste of time or might something actually come out of them? Share your thoughts with us in the HEXUS.lifestyle news forum.

HEXUS.links

HEXUS.community :: discussion thread about this article
HEXUS.community :: posting on Evesham iplayer thread about Openhdtv petition

HEXUS.lifestyle - reviews :: Evesham iplayer - Freeview HD PVR, network media player & more

External.links

E-Petitions - Openhdtv E-Petition
E-Petitons - home page

Ofcom - Digital Dividend Review - consultation
Ofcom - contacts page



HEXUS Forums :: 4 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
These online petitions aren't so that they can see what the public wants and then do it. It's so that they can make sure they really are ignoring what we want done by having the statistics to back it up :)
These E-Petitions are just like Mr Blair himself, a waste of time and energy.

They never listen to the public and the petition regarding road charging is a prime example.

If you want them to take notice, use your vote for someone else instead of filling in these :)
The only upside of the online petitions that i can think of is that it gets people talking and being more politically aware.

We can only hope this will rub off and get more poeple to the polls when the time comes.
I expected the blizzard of anti-government anti-Blair sentiment on here.

Even if you don't like Blair, the petitions get (some) people thinking about political issues, get them more involved, and will hopefully lead to other forms of activism. Frankly, did you expect government policy to be made based on a couple of thousand online votes?

Now, to be a bit controversial, listening to the public is important, but the public is generally driven by short term interests and most of us aren't experts on issues that the government has to deal with (some people here may be experts on IT systems, and know what kind of system the NHS should get, but few of us will be experts on dealing with young offenders or reducing death rates from certain diseases.)

My point is that lots of us have opinions on things, but just because we do, it doesn't mean that the government should always act on them.

PS. I don't like the national road pricing idea, I like the sound of the HD idea, I have mixed feelings towards Blair, and I think “Dave” Cameron and Blair are almost interchangeable.