facebook rss twitter

Review: ATI All-In-Wonder X1800 XL - First Hands-On Look

by Bob Crabtree on 23 November 2005, 06:21

Tags: ATi Technologies (NYSE:AMD)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qad3w

Add to My Vault: x

Test system


Without the help of MESH Computers, we wouldn't have been able to bring you this preview but, even with it, we've ended up delivering a lot later than we'd intended. However, we weren't willing to go live until we were reasonably happy with the article and so it's gone up two days later than planned. Perhaps we were just a little over ambitious.

A few words about our take on build quality and the like. If we have any criticism (and, of course we do), it's largely down to the fact that - because of time-constraints - one of the system chassis cooling fans used hadn't been specifically tailored to suit the ATI card. The ATI All-In-Wonder X1800 XL was surprisingly and acceptably quiet and merited components to match and, with one exception, they did.

The AKASA CPU cooler fan wasn't noisy and nor was the 120mm Chieftec fan venting air from the rear of the case. Even the fan on the 550W HEC 550TD-PDE power supply was okay. However, fully assembled, the machine was rather noisier than we'd have liked and it turned out that the offender was the 85x85mm Chieftec D80SM-12 attached to the chassis' left side panel. This serves to force air along a short corrugated tube onto the CPU cooler fan. With the left side panel removed (no tools required - there's a lockable quick-release mechanism) and it's safe for us to disconnect the fan without fear of overheating, the noise level dropped considerably and it became clear how remarkably quiet the AIW's on-board fan is.


Chassis side panel of MESH PC showing CPU fan in tube Chassis side panel removed to show corrugated tube,
at the base of which is a fan to blow air over the CPU



Chieftect D80SM-12 fan from Mesh PC The Chieftec fan within the tube is rather noisy

Our hope - and our expectation - is that a quieter side panel fan will be used in any system the company builds containing an All-In-Wonder X1800 XL.

We've already pointed out the problem that the MESH-installed Cyberlink software suite caused us, and we also fully expect that to be resolved in any such AIW-based system.

Those two issues apart, we were very happy with the MESH system and its components. The case is good-enough looking (but a swine to photograph because of its silver and black front) and has plenty of drive bays - four 5.25in external and three 3.5in internal. With the drives that had been installed - using quick-release fittings, we should add - one bay of each type was left free. We'd have like to have seen a FireWire port around the front, rather than just a pair of USB 2.0 sockets but with two FireWire sockets round the back - along with four further USB ports - we probably would be ungracious to do more than raise an eyebrow.

MESH PC front Front of MESH PC



Rear of MESH PC Rear of MESH PC

The ASUS A8R-MVP motherboard - which we'd recommended be used - is well spec'd and laid out in such a way that all sockets are readily accessed, and with no daft things such as memory-release handles only being able to be used when the graphics card has been removed.

MESH PC interior Interior. Neat and tidy layout with good access to key
areas of the motherboard
. The lower red arrow points
to a power plug, and this goes into a socket at the end of
the ATI card - indicated by the left-most arrow. The
larger red arrow shows the Molex plug that takes
power to the fan on the removable side wall
(removed, of course, to take this shot ). The fan
blows air over the CPU. The case is lockable - note
the key in the lock, with spare below, at top left

MESH PC - side Sideview. The top vent is for the CPU blower fan. The
bottom one is passive. Once unlocked, the side panel
is released using the lever at top centre

Maxtor was MESH's chosen HDD supplier and the two large-capacity Serial ATA drives performed speedily and quietly. The motherboard has a further pair of available SATA ports but only a single EIDE connector and this was being fully used by the two DVD drives.

We'd love to have told you how much we like the Creative Labs 7.1-capable sound card and speakers but we never took the speakers out of their boxes nor listened to sound on anything other than our own headphones - there wasn't sufficient space in our lab at the time. That's also partly the reason why we didn't try out the supplied ViewSonic monitor - the other is that we prefer to control all systems through a single keyboard/monitor/mouse switchbox, and so we did just that. Not surprisingly, use of our KVM box meant we also left untouched the supplied Logitech cordless keyboard/mouse pairing.

Finally - cabling. That was neat and tidy, but with MESH's long-standing experience, we'd have been disappointed if it hadn't been. Having tidy cabling didn't simply mean that everything looked ship-shaped but that - combined with the case design and motherboard layout - every component was easily accessible for maintenance or upgrade, and no fans were obscured or at risk of being fouled.

So, thanks people - good job.

TEST SYSTEM

MESH Computers - MatriX2 1800AIW (Hexus Jan 06)

System maker

MESH Computers

System name

MatriX2 1800AIW (Hexus Jan 06)

System price

£1,349 (ex VAT); £1,585.08 (inc VAT)

CPU

AMD Athlon 64 X2 Dual-core 4400+ with HT Tech

Operating system

Microsoft Windows XP Professional Edition

System case

Midi-Tower ATX in black & silver

Power supply

550W PSU

Motherboard

ASUS A8R-MVP; ATI Xpress 200 PCI; ATX

RAM

1,024MB DDR400 Memory - PC3200 (2x512MB)

HDD1

200GB Serial ATA with 8MB Buffer

HDD2

300GB Serial ATA with 16MB Buffer

Optical 1

16x DVD-ROM Drive (40x CD-ROM)

Optical 2

SONY 16x Dual Layer DVD-Rewritable +R/-R/RW

Graphics 1

256MB ATI Radeon XI800XL All-in-Wonder - PCI-Express; DVI & VGA; analogue/digital TV tuner (+FM radio); TV out; S-video in/out; component video out

Graphics 2

N/A

Monitor 1

19in ViewSonic VX924 TFT flat panel monitor - DVI (3ms)

Monitor 2

N/A

Monitor cables

1 x DVI

Sound card

Creative Labs Sound Blaster X-Fl Xtreme Music

Speakers

Creative Labs Inspire T7900 - 7.1 Surround with Subwoofer

Keyboard

Logitech Cordless Keyboard & Rechargeable Cordless Mouse

Mouse

See above

Software 1

Free Microsoft Works 8.5 + 60 Days Microsoft Office trial

Software 2

Free Cyberlink Video Editing Suite - seven titles (OEM)

Software 3

eTrust Antivirus V7 - 90 days trial

Modem

56Kbps internal V92 - voice, data and fax.

Floppy disk drive

1.44MB - 3.5in

Media player

40GB Media Box - BNI-501 Portable Media Library (USB 2.0)


MESH Computers

Web:
http://www.meshcomputers.com
Sales
HotLine: 08700 46 47 47
Email:
sales@meshcomputers.com

Snail:

MESH Computers PLC
MESH House
No. 1 Oxgate Centre
Oxgate Lane
London NW2 7JA