facebook rss twitter

Review: Thecus N5500 five-bay enterprise NAS and DAS. Worth £575?

by Tarinder Sandhu on 4 September 2009, 05:00 3.45

Tags: Thecus N5500, Thecus (4978.TWO)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qatpy

Add to My Vault: x

Performance results

IOMeter 64KB sequential read
QNAP TS-509 Pro (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (single Gigabit)
105.4644.89103.96


Using a 1GB test file and evaluated via the 64KB sequential read test, the N5500's performance is less than half the similarly-specified QNAP TS-509 Pro when run via dual-Gigabit, suggesting sub-optimal firmware. The single-Gigabit speed is much better, clearly. Neither NAS appliance is able to breach the single-Gigabit speed barrier of 125MB/s.

IOMeter 64KB sequential write
QNAP TS-509 Pro (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (single Gigabit)
70.2357.5693.89


Sequential writing speed continues to be better on the single connection, although 57.6MB/s can be deemed as reasonable throughput.

IOMeter 64KB random read and write
QNAP TS-509 Pro (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (single Gigabit)
12.2719.3820.78


Hitting the NAS boxes some, randomised reading and writing is comparatively good on the N5500.

IOMeter 1MB sequential read
QNAP TS-509 Pro (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (dual Gigabit)Thecus N5500 (single Gigabit)
41.5444.1439.85


As is the 1MB transfer test.

FTP speed

Hooking the N5500 up to a high-end Core i7 test rig via (single) Gigabit Ethernet and FTP, we managed a download speed of 19.2MB/s and upload of 35.1MB/s when transferring a 5.25GB file to and from the host computer. The results are a little lower than we'd hope for, especially from a high-end NAS.