facebook rss twitter

Review: Toshiba Satellite Pro A300D notebook: AMD Puma at the helm

by Tarinder Sandhu on 10 October 2008, 17:17 2.5

Tags: Satellite Pro A300D, Toshiba (TYO:6502), AMD (NYSE:AMD)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qapp4

Add to My Vault: x

HEXUS.gaming, HEXUS.hd, HEXUS.battery

HEXUS.hd - QuickTime 1080p clip (h.264) playback load
HP Pavilion TX2520Dell XPS M1330Dell Inspiron 690GNovatech Centrino 2Toshiba Satellite A300DToshiba Satellite Pro A300D
40.130.5540.724.537.5543.44


HEXUS.gaming - Quake 4 v1.30 netdemo - 1,280x800 0xAA 8xAF
HP Pavilion TX2520Dell XPS M1330Dell Inspiron 690GNovatech Centrino 2Toshiba Satellite A300DToshiba Satellite Pro A300D
25.6635.3514.117.2567.6525.25


The Satellite features a discrete Mobility Radeon HD 3650 512MB graphics card, hence the high scores. Likewise, the Dell XPS M1330 packs in a low-end, discrete GeForce 8400M GS. Take another look at the graph, without those two, and we're left with IGP-based solutions, with Puma besting Centrino 2's X4500MHD. The venerable game is surprisingly playable at the screen's native resolution.

HEXUS.battery - percentage left after 60m Batman Begins DVD
HP Pavilion TX2520Dell XPS M1330Dell Inspiron 690GNovatech Centrino 2Toshiba Satellite A300DToshiba Satellite Pro A300D
517242393236


You may wonder why the battery-life isn't substantially better than the Satellite's. It should be, because the Pro uses energy-saving IGP graphics and the same-size battery. The answer has to do with Toshiba's build, where the DVD playback software, branded Toshiba, consistently takes around 80 per cent CPU load when displaying the film.



Note the 90 per cent overall load which will strip the battery down faster than you can say 'Call me Brenda and slap my thigh, hard'. It's a problem that we believe to be sample-specific yet it's worrying nonetheless.

As a comparison, the Satellite Pro, which is practically identical, averages around 35 per cent CPU load, and that's with a discrete graphics card that chews through watts.