facebook rss twitter

Apple iPad: a new lease of life for the ill-fated tablet?

by Parm Mann on 1 February 2010, 10:42

Tags: iPad, Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qavuc

Add to My Vault: x

Where does it fit in?

There isn't a shortage of devices that offer functionality similar to that of the iPad, but to see how Apple's solution stacks up to some of the competition, we've picked out a few of the most popular alternatives to see how the iPad compares.

The below table briefly outlines the hardware, functionality and pricing of seven popular products - including a smartphone, an e-reader, tablets, netbooks and notebooks.

 
Smartphone
E-reader
Tablet
Netbook
Notebook
Product Apple iPhone 3GS Amazon Kindle DX Apple iPad Archos 9 Dell Inspiron Mini 10 Dell Studio XPS 13 Apple Macbook
Processor, speed Samsung, 600MHz Freescale, 532MHz Apple A4, 1GHz Intel Atom, 1.1GHz Intel Atom, 1.6GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, 2.2GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, 2.2GHz
Display 3.5in LCD
480x320
9.7in e-ink
1,200x824
9.7in LED backlit
1,024x768
8.9in LED backlit
1,024x600
10.1in widescreen
1,024x600
1,366x768 (optional)
13.3in CCFL LCD
1,280x800
13.3in LED backlit
1,280x800
Input Capacitive multi-touch screen Button-based five-way controller
QWERTY keyboard
Capacitive multi-touch screen Resistive touch screen Multi-touch trackpad
QWERTY keyboard
Multi-touch trackpad
QWERTY keyboard
Multi-touch trackpad
QWERTY keyboard
Storage 16GB 32GB 4GB 16GB 32GB 64GB 60GB 160GB + 320GB + 250GB +
Camera 3 megapixel N/A N/A 1.3 megapixel webcam 1.3 megapixel webcam 2.0 megapixel webcam iSight webcam (640x480)
Connectivity

Wi-Fi 802.11b/g
Bluetooth 2.1
3G

3G Wi-Fi 802.11b/g/n
Bluetooth 2.1
3G (optional)
Wi-Fi 802.11b/g
Bluetooth 2.0
Ethernet
Wi-Fi 802.11b/g/n
Bluetooth 2.1
Ethernet
Wi-Fi 802.11b/g/n
Bluetooth 2.0
Gigabit Ethernet
Wi-Fi 802.11b/g/n
Bluetooth 2.1
Gigabit Ethernet
Data plans Start at £20 per month Free 3G connectivity Optional N/A Optional N/A N/A
Accelerometer Yes Yes Yes No No No No
GPS Advanced No No No No No No
Weight 0.14kg 0.54kg 0.68kg 0.80kg 1.20kg 2.20kg 2.13kg
Operating system iPhone OS Kindle OS iPhone OS Windows 7 Starter Windows 7 Starter Windows 7 Home Premium Mac OS X
Functionality
Phone / SMS Yes No No No No No No
Web browser Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Flash support No N/A No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Email client Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Video chat No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Music playback Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Video playback Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Integrated app store Yes No Yes No No No No
Custom apps No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
E-book client No Yes (Kindle) Yes (iBooks) Third-party (Kindle for PC) Third-party (Kindle for PC) Third-party (Kindle for PC) Third-party
Games Yes (basic) No Yes (basic) Yes (basic) Yes (basic) Yes Yes
Office productivity No No Yes (iWorks) Yes Yes Yes Yes
Multi-tasking No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Pricing
Device only £449 £549 £383 £499* £599* £699* £460 £309 £749 £816
*speculative pricing, UK pricing yet to be confirmed.

[advert]

Taking the above data into consideration, it's easy to ascertain why the iPad has been described by many as a larger iPhone/iPod touch.

Yet, despite offering much of the same functionality, the two are very much unique in their own ways. The iPad is unable to make calls and doesn't feature a built-in camera - ruling out any possibility of video chat - but unlike the iPhone/iPod touch, it offers a larger screen, a faster processor, and added capabilities for office productivity and e-reading.

The ability to create and edit documents using Apple's iWork office suite suggests the iPad is moving firmly into personal computer territory, but not quite. Despite the added functionality, the iPad is still some way from tablet PC/notebook standards. At present, it offers no support for Adobe Flash-based content - the ubiquitous format used to deliver the majority of the Internet's video content - and there's no means of installing your own apps. Unless you can find it in the Apple-approved app store, you'll be unable to install your web browser of choice, or popular software packages such as Microsoft Office.

Furthermore, unlike other tablets or notebooks, and like Apple's own smartphone, the iPad currently suffers from an inability to multi-task. In terms of usage, that means you're restricted to running one application at a time.

Clearly, the iPad is something of an anomaly. In terms of functionality and usage, it's like no smartphone, tablet or notebook before it - it's an entirely new category of device, but is that a bad thing?