facebook rss twitter

Review: Belkin USB Dual Media Reader/Writer

by Tarinder Sandhu on 1 June 2002, 00:00

Tags: Belkin

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qalu

Add to My Vault: x

Specification/Installation & Conclusion

Specifications in detail

  • Supports both CompactFlash (Type I and Type II) and SmartMedia (both 3.3 and 5v)

  • Full compliance with USB v1.1

  • Plug-and-play, hot-swap capability

  • Data transfer speeds of 12Mbps

  • Powers through USB port, no external power sources required

  • Compact, stackable design

  • Drag and drop transfer

  • Lifetime warranty

Installation

I use Windows XP Operating System and installation could not be simpler. I simply connected up the supplied USB lead to the unit and Windows XP did the rest. Device manager simply saw the reader/writer as a couple of new hard drives as shown below.

Windows Explorer saw it as a couple of removable drives too, it couldn't be easier to install. The CompactFlash drive was given the I: status whilst the SmartMedia drive was allotted J: status on my PC.

Usage

Installation was a breeze and so was usage. The fact that Windows sees it as another two hard drives, and treats it accordingly, means that reader/writer is offered hard drive privileges such as drag and drop, delete, format and folder creation and deletion.

The above picture shows me copying a home-made 62MB AVI movie from one of my hard drives to a 128MB CompactFlash card. I wanted to play this in my IPAQ 3850 PDA and this was the easiest method of transfer. The IPAQs built-in USB transfer was markedly slower in comparison. The whole transfer took just under a minute, thus giving us an average transfer speed of over 1MB/s. Reading from the IPAQ to the PC was an equally simple affair.

The fact that it can quickly transfer files effectively means that a large CompactFlash or SmartMedia card can be used as a temporary storage medium between two computers who both have readers/writers. To this end, I transferred 100MB of various data quickly and efficiently on to a CF card and read that back on to another computer with a similar reader/writer, simple and elegant. The SmartMedia performance was impressive, too.

I have no complaints at all on the performance front, it does exactly what it says on the box with the minimum of fuss.

Conclusion

The increasing number of Flash-type storage devices means that users could potentially benefit from a reader/writer. The in-built transfer software of CompactFlash and SmartMedia devices sometimes leaves a lot to be desired. Here is where the Belkin USB Dual Media Reader/Writer comes in useful. It's well-built, intuitively easy to use, a cinch to install, and performs exactly as one would expect. The fact that it is powered through the USB port it a bonus. Two popular forms of media are catered for with both Windows and Mac software support.

The R.R.P of Ā£44.99 is quite steep when compared to some of the competition, especially those who offer in-built support for more removable media formats such as MMC (MultiMedia) and SD (Secure Digital) cards as standard. Belkin provide readers/writers for these formats too.

In summary, if you're looking for a no-frills CompactFlash and SmartMedia reader/writer, from a well-respected company, coupled with the peace of mind from a lifetime warranty, the Belkin unit could just be for you. Recommended.