facebook rss twitter

Review: Fractal Design Kelvin S24

by Parm Mann on 9 December 2014, 12:00

Tags: Fractal Design

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qacmgn

Add to My Vault: x

Conclusion

...as a mid-pack offering for performance users, the 240mm Kelvin S24 is a capable package that tackles overclocked CPUs with ease.

Fractal Design has entered the liquid-cooling market with a range of solutions designed in collaboration with Alphacool.

The initial trio of Kelvin Series coolers offers full-copper construction, a choice of form factors, stylish aesthetics and, perhaps crucially, standard fitting for simplified expandability.

Potential caveats include pump noise, which continues to be a weak spot for many liquid coolers, and a £90 price tag that puts the Kelvin S24 up against an established set of competitors.

Good build quality and a thoughtful bundle help account for the fee, and as a mid-pack offering for performance users, the 240mm Kelvin S24 is a capable package that tackles overclocked CPUs with ease. Straightforward installation is part of the appeal, and in clearing the clutter from around the CPU socket, the S24 can be a key component in achieving an attractive PC build.

The Good
 
The Bad
Expandable
Excellent performance
Good build quality throughout
Straightforward installation
Doesn't clutter the CPU socket
Simple, sleek design
 
Pump noise can be bothersome
Pricey at £90



Fractal Design Kelvin S24

HEXUS where to buy

TBC.

HEXUS right to reply

At HEXUS, we invite the companies whose products we test to comment on our articles. If any company representatives for the products reviewed choose to respond, we'll publish their commentary here verbatim.

Heili Toome, Brand Manager for Fractal Design, has issued the following right2reply:

[December 09, 2014]

Thank you, HEXUS, for reviewing the Kelvin S24 and awarding it as ‘HEXUS Approved’! It’s reassuring to know that professionals like your team recognize our products in high regard.

In regards to the reported pump noise at 12V, we would like to clarify this as one may run the system ‘as is’ in a more silent environment (at 9V) but also have the ability and convenience of running the pump at 12V and expanding your system, giving users more options.

The pump speed is set at 12V because at any lower level the system might not be able to handle additional components like GPU (expandability). We have focused efforts to silence the pump through noise insulation materials etc, but it is not possible to completely remove the noise. If you look at other models (systems that are expected to handle more heat output basically), they may also have relatively noisy pumps because running them at lower speeds reduces the cooling performance significantly and also puts the life time of the product at risk.

At 12V, the pump is going to emit some sound. However, the user has the opportunity to lower the voltage under 12V and the pump will be much more silent. The tradeoff is that you may lose performance and cannot expand with GPUs etc. We have been very adamant about communicating that the pump should run at 12V as there is a concern surrounding the lifetime of the product and the warranty. However, the pump can be used at 9V speed without any lifetime issues. It may be harder to handle a GPU in the loop and may lose performance, but the Kelvin Series overall can be quite silent at 9V and the warranty will support this.



HEXUS Forums :: 9 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
I'd love to see a kit with a pump, hoses and radiator in a neat package (possibly with pump built into radiator) leaving you the choice to buy a cpu or gpu water block. I'd get one to cool my 970 but wouldn't want it sharing the same preheated water that my CPU uses.
DemonHighwayman
I'd love to see a kit with a pump, hoses and radiator in a neat package (possibly with pump built into radiator) leaving you the choice to buy a cpu or gpu water block. I'd get one to cool my 970 but wouldn't want it sharing the same preheated water that my CPU uses.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm sure it's been thoroughly proven that ‘warm water’ has at best a margin of error change on temps.

It's all the same at the end of the day, as long as you have enough surface area on the radiators then just bang it all in a loop. This way you only need one pump and one res. :)
I know Swifttech make rad&pump combo's (not a whole kit just these two bits in one) I know that the early versions had some major issues with vibration.
The pump being hard mounted to the rad, which in turn is hard mounted to the case means you've got a lot of mass getting vibrated and if it's not tightly bolted to the case then that vibration get tuned into knocking.
The early ones also had an acrylic reservoir on the other end of the rad, and the vibrations caused the reservoir joints to crack and leak, this was fixed in the later models with a metal reservoir incorporated into the body of the rad.

As to warm water effecting the temperatures, depends on the setup, there's a lot of factors that go into it, contact surface area, head pressure, water flow speed, temperature differentials.

Personally I'd like to be able to just buy the pump/block separately.

Also as with almost every other all-in-one cooler review on almost every other site, there's no opening it up to see what the insides are like under the shiny plastic casing. :(
I really wish some reviews would take the time to pop some of these open to actually see what the internal differences actually are.
The Swiftech H220-X has a pump mounted in the radiator. I'm in the market for a 240mm AIO water cooler and waited for this model but they are impossible to get hold of in the UK.

This Fractal looks quite nice but I think it needs more coolers in the review to give a feel of how it stacks up, especially against the popular models like the Corsairs.
DemonHighwayman
I'd love to see a kit with a pump, hoses and radiator in a neat package (possibly with pump built into radiator) leaving you the choice to buy a cpu or gpu water block. I'd get one to cool my 970 but wouldn't want it sharing the same preheated water that my CPU uses.

The specific heat capacity of water is so high that at normal flow rates there genuinely isn't a significant difference in temperature at different points in the loop, counter-intuitive though that is.
Your water temperature before and after your CPU will be within a degree or so of each other, all that matters is that the radiator is able to keep on top of the heat being put into the loop.