HEXUS Forums :: 22 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Posted by Cr@ig - Mon 06 Apr 2020 12:52
Good luck finding customers
Posted by Spreadie - Mon 06 Apr 2020 12:59
Cr@ig;4191085
Good luck finding customers

Why? XPS laptops typically perform and sell well.

You don't have to leave your house to buy one either.
Posted by Output - Mon 06 Apr 2020 13:31
Until they offer configurations with AMD CPUs too, I can't see the appeal of choosing Dell (and similar OEMs') systems in the current environment where AMD offers serious performance and better value.
Posted by excalibur1814 - Mon 06 Apr 2020 14:30
Never underestimate the pull of that intel badge. It still holds weight, despite any review or reason.
Posted by Nelviticus - Mon 06 Apr 2020 14:47
If that really _is_ the XPS 17 on the right it seems a terrible shame to have omitted the numeric keypad. There's plenty of room for it.
Posted by philehidiot - Mon 06 Apr 2020 23:01
excalibur1814
Never underestimate the pull of that intel badge. It still holds weight, despite any review or reason.

Absolutely. I remember back in the days of the Athlon64 and P4. You'd have had to be mad to buy a P4 but my work bought them by the pallet.

I can definitely see where there are some workloads which are simply optimised for Intel. Also, stability problems and little niggles here and there and everywhere are still apparent in AMD software.

If I was buying a machine for workstation use of this size, I'd not buy one without a numeric keypad. Yes you can plug one in but that's desk space wasted and more hardware to buy, store, break, etc.

I suspect a lot of IT departments are looking at the latest AMD hardware compared to Intel's position and seriously considering their positions. I hope common sense prevails.
Posted by Gentle Viking - Tue 07 Apr 2020 02:14
My kid sister have a laptop that i think hold a dualcore semperon or something like that, it is pretty miserable for sure, so fortunate for her she don't use it often.

And i would love to buy 2 new AMD laptops, one for her and one for me.
Also don't get the hybrids, with a brand spanking new AMD heart but a Nvidia GFX.
Posted by Myss_tree - Tue 07 Apr 2020 07:05
A numeric keypad is a total irrelevance to me so the lack of is a plus to me.
I like the small bezels and that its more than 1920 x 1080. If its touchscreen and a reasonable price then i will be interested.
Posted by DanceswithUnix - Tue 07 Apr 2020 07:35
excalibur1814
Never underestimate the pull of that intel badge. It still holds weight, despite any review or reason.

TBH I think the Dell badge has more sway in companies than the Intel badge. Dell's consumer gear has a pretty bad rep but I think the business Dell range is still good reliable stuff.

Hence I have always said, I will believe AMD are making proper inroads when I can buy an AMD based Dell workstation. Frankly, a decent HP one would be a nice start.
Posted by Spud1 - Tue 07 Apr 2020 09:30
Output
Until they offer configurations with AMD CPUs too, I can't see the appeal of choosing Dell (and similar OEMs') systems in the current environment where AMD offers serious performance and better value.

Quality is the main reason - the XPS range (particularly the XPS 13) is really well put together, good components, very good casing, good support and at a sensible price.

I don't quite get why the fact it's an intel is a massive turn off - the chips provide good performance, the machines will be priced sensibly, so what's the issue?

I am typically an Intel buyer purely based on the performance for my use case scenario in desktops, but in laptops i'm much less picky, particularly when neither the latest AMD or Intel chips have a particular advantage over the other in the vast majority of use cases.

The OEM and build quality matters much more to me. Sadly Dell are still refusing to put a dGPU in their 13" chassis so i'm holding out for the Surface Book 3's which are also expected soon. Fingers crossed MS make another gaming ultrabook this time around :)
Posted by rave_alan - Tue 07 Apr 2020 11:07
The previous one had gorgeous display, almost as good as mac's).If the battery life is as good as mac's air, the price is competitive, bild quality is already fine, why not=)
Posted by Output - Tue 07 Apr 2020 11:39
Spud1
I don't quite get why the fact it's an intel is a massive turn off - the chips provide good performance, the machines will be priced sensibly, so what's the issue?

It's a matter of there being a lack of choice in CPU manufacturer. Not offering AMD CPUs too just isn't giving fair comparisons and choices for the OEMs' customers, when it's entirely possible that AMD would be the better and/or preferred route for their desired usage cases.

That's not to say Intel wouldn't be the better and/or preferred route for some, but rather that the more types of CPUs that are available, the more choice and configurability there would be and thus it would be better for the customers (and possibly the OEMs' profits too).
Posted by Xlucine - Tue 07 Apr 2020 11:41
Spud1
Quality is the main reason - the XPS range (particularly the XPS 13) is really well put together, good components, very good casing, good support and at a sensible price.

I don't quite get why the fact it's an intel is a massive turn off - the chips provide good performance, the machines will be priced sensibly, so what's the issue?

I am typically an Intel buyer purely based on the performance for my use case scenario in desktops, but in laptops i'm much less picky, particularly when neither the latest AMD or Intel chips have a particular advantage over the other in the vast majority of use cases.

The OEM and build quality matters much more to me. Sadly Dell are still refusing to put a dGPU in their 13" chassis so i'm holding out for the Surface Book 3's which are also expected soon. Fingers crossed MS make another gaming ultrabook this time around :)

Pricing so far has AMD 8 core laptops priced equivalent to intel 6 core laptops, which is a pretty big gulf in performance. Sensible pricing would be i9s for ryzen 7 money, and no-one's offering that
Posted by Spud1 - Tue 07 Apr 2020 11:53
Xlucine
Pricing so far has AMD 8 core laptops priced equivalent to intel 6 core laptops, which is a pretty big gulf in performance. Sensible pricing would be i9s for ryzen 7 money, and no-one's offering that

Only if you need the extra cores, which most people don't yet…real world performance is largely similar, so it comes down to pricing. I'm not in any way saying that a specific Intel mobile option is generally “better” or “worse”, just that as with the desktop lineup, which is better for you depends on your use case and how much you can afford to spend…

Sadly I don't think we'll ever realistically get one OEM producing AMD and Intel “versions” of the same machine - at least not in the mid-high end sector…the boards & components are typically custom designed for a given chassis, and the cost of producing two designs that give consumers essentially the same thing doesn't make sense. Very different to the PC market where most parts are off the shelf so its much cheaper to offer flexibility.

We're more likely to see specific OEMs siding with Red or Blue imo, but I don't really care - if someone can make a 13" Ultrabook with good single thread performance & a current gen dGPU…i'll be all over it. Don't really care if its AMD, Intel, Nvidia, or all three :)
Posted by Xlucine - Wed 08 Apr 2020 14:44
Spud1
Only if you need the extra cores, which most people don't yet…real world performance is largely similar, so it comes down to pricing. I'm not in any way saying that a specific Intel mobile option is generally “better” or “worse”, just that as with the desktop lineup, which is better for you depends on your use case and how much you can afford to spend…

Sadly I don't think we'll ever realistically get one OEM producing AMD and Intel “versions” of the same machine - at least not in the mid-high end sector…the boards & components are typically custom designed for a given chassis, and the cost of producing two designs that give consumers essentially the same thing doesn't make sense. Very different to the PC market where most parts are off the shelf so its much cheaper to offer flexibility.

We're more likely to see specific OEMs siding with Red or Blue imo, but I don't really care - if someone can make a 13" Ultrabook with good single thread performance & a current gen dGPU…i'll be all over it. Don't really care if its AMD, Intel, Nvidia, or all three :)

In CPU limited games you can see faster performance on the ryzen side, and this will get worse with the new consoles:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sePCp3LwEC0

For web browsing they're all the same as a chromebook, but a lot needs the cores these days. At best the intel matches the ryzen chip, and it's beaten soundly in real world tests like battery life. “Good performance” doesn't include getting beaten in every way by price equivalent competition
Posted by Ttaskmaster - Wed 08 Apr 2020 18:55
Super secret image accidentally slips out…. and it….. it looks like…. a laptop.
Wow, I can see why they'd want this kept under wraps.

Our work machines are Dell. Mine is a Precision 3530 with an i7 8850H and 32GB of RAM, but I'm special and get a fancy one. Everyone else has a 13" one for easy portable hotdesking.
I presume these are actually cheaper than any AMD option, though. We don't buy anything unless it's cheap… or unless the supplier is a mate of the CEO!! :D
Posted by six_tymes - Fri 10 Apr 2020 12:50
Output
Until they offer configurations with AMD CPUs too, I can't see the appeal of choosing Dell (and similar OEMs') systems in the current environment where AMD offers serious performance and better value.

and don't forget amd offers instability, and over heating procs.
Posted by Output - Fri 10 Apr 2020 13:02
six_tymes
and don't forget amd offers instability, and over heating procs.

Not sure where you got that from, as I would consider AMD to be very stable, with no overheating issues.
Posted by Jonj1611 - Fri 10 Apr 2020 13:08
I agree, AMD is a different processor entirely these days
Posted by Cr@ig - Mon 13 Apr 2020 04:20
Output
Until they offer configurations with AMD CPUs too, I can't see the appeal of choosing Dell (and similar OEMs') systems in the current environment where AMD offers serious performance and better value.

Who's got a job now? Again good luck finding customers as I predicted?
Posted by Cr@ig - Mon 13 Apr 2020 04:24
Who's got a job now??? As I predicted who's going to buy one?
Posted by Output - Mon 13 Apr 2020 11:27
Cr@ig;4193713
Who's got a job now? Again good luck finding customers as I predicted?

By ‘current environment’ I was referring on this particular occasion to the Zen 2 architecture's existence, providing a lot of performance, including in laptops with their new 4000 series mobile Ryzens (judging from a Linux Tech Tips video recently for the latter).

As for the effect the lockdown is having on the ability of people to buy, there will still be some people buying now (other than the obvious work-from-home orders), even it's likely a lot less than in normal times, and after things get back to normal there will probably be an increase in demand again.