HEXUS Forums :: 16 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Posted by Ravens Nest - Fri 03 Apr 2020 10:56
HEXUS
Read more.

I wish they would just jump DDR5 and go straight to DDR6, the PS5 and Xbox series X will have 16GB DDR6 as standard so I think anything new that comes to PC now should be at least that.
Posted by 3dcandy - Fri 03 Apr 2020 11:14
The consoles are using GDDR6 not DDR6. Different beast totally…
Posted by Ravens Nest - Fri 03 Apr 2020 11:39
3dcandy
The consoles are using GDDR6 not DDR6. Different beast totally…

Ok thanks for the correction, only thing is the consoles use it for the whole system not just graphics.

So i'm guessing the PC accesses the CPU mostly so DDR5 is lower bandwidth tighter timing more efficient for CPU access whereas GDDR6 is high bandwidth loose timing better for GPU i guess.

Just found this explanation it was quite helpful.

https://www.hardwaretimes.com/difference-between-ddr4-vs-gddr5-vs-gddr6-memory-ddr4-vs-lpddr4-comparison-whats-hbm2/
Posted by philehidiot - Fri 03 Apr 2020 13:04
Consoles use GDDR as system memory?

Myself I've only just moved from DDR3 to DDR4. Please don't make my new system obsolete as soon as I've built it….
Posted by Gentle Viking - Fri 03 Apr 2020 13:12
I will take new hardware ( CPU - MOBO ) with 8 X 64 GB DDR8400 RAM.
Only problem is no one will buy it for me

My current CPU will not push 64Gb of RAM at 3600 MHZ, it will only do that with 32GB, so i have to make do with just shy of 3500 MHZ cuz i cant be bothered with tweaking it more.
Posted by 3dcandy - Fri 03 Apr 2020 13:22
philehidiot
Consoles use GDDR as system memory?

Myself I've only just moved from DDR3 to DDR4. Please don't make my new system obsolete as soon as I've built it….

Next gen yes. Quickest memory/most bandwidth and available now
;)
Posted by 3dcandy - Fri 03 Apr 2020 13:23
Gentle Viking;4190083
I will take new hardware ( CPU - MOBO ) with 8 X 64 GB DDR8400 RAM.
Only problem is no one will buy it for me

My current CPU will not push 64Gb of RAM at 3600 MHZ, it will only do that with 32GB, so i have to make do with just shy of 3500 MHZ cuz i cant be bothered with tweaking it more.

Only 16 gig of 3000 here. Ryzen 7 2700 won't go higher without odd cold boot issue
Posted by philehidiot - Fri 03 Apr 2020 13:47
3dcandy
Next gen yes. Quickest memory/most bandwidth and available now
;)

I suppose they really don't have to care about general system performance that much…. there will be more than enough grunt there to overcome the inefficiencies brought in by using suboptimal memory for the occasional application.
Posted by Peter Parker - Fri 03 Apr 2020 14:06
Is ECC part of the DDR5 spec? I can't find any details about that elsewhere, so perhaps it's a value-add just for this manufacturer.

I once read an estimate of a cosmic ray flipping a bit at once per decade per 8GB. So in a 64GB workstation that's every year or two, and in servers that'd be every few months :(
Posted by 3dcandy - Fri 03 Apr 2020 14:21
philehidiot
I suppose they really don't have to care about general system performance that much…. there will be more than enough grunt there to overcome the inefficiencies brought in by using suboptimal memory for the occasional application.

There will be millions sold they will get a great price. It's about cost V performance on a console anyhoo
Posted by 3dcandy - Fri 03 Apr 2020 14:22
Peter Parker;4190143
Is ECC part of the DDR5 spec? I can't find any details about that elsewhere, so perhaps it's a value-add just for this manufacturer.

I once read an estimate of a cosmic ray flipping a bit at once per decade per 8GB. So in a 64GB workstation that's every year or two, and in servers that'd be every few months :(

I *think* ECC is part of the spec….
Posted by PMMEASURES - Fri 03 Apr 2020 14:26
Big difference is these console's have the ram very close to the CPU so less issue with long length track traces in interference and timing differences. Classic PC memory is more further away and more likely the reason it lags behind a couple of sped generations from its GDDR equivalent.
Posted by Tabbykatze - Fri 03 Apr 2020 14:55
Peter Parker;4190143
Is ECC part of the DDR5 spec? I can't find any details about that elsewhere, so perhaps it's a value-add just for this manufacturer.

I once read an estimate of a cosmic ray flipping a bit at once per decade per 8GB. So in a 64GB workstation that's every year or two, and in servers that'd be every few months :(



On-die ECC is part of the spec.
Posted by Corky34 - Fri 03 Apr 2020 15:07
PMMEASURES
Big difference is these console's have the ram very close to the CPU so less issue with long length track traces in interference and timing differences. Classic PC memory is more further away and more likely the reason it lags behind a couple of sped generations from its GDDR equivalent.
While that does make a difference I'm not sure an extra few inches would be noticeable from an overall system perspective, we're talking about a signal travelling at something like 50 to 90 odd percent of the speed of light, IIRC that's roughly 12 inches per nanosecond so at most you'd be talking about 1ns.
Posted by PMMEASURES - Fri 03 Apr 2020 17:49
It not so the travel speed but interference(Signal Quality), track trace resistance, capacitance rf interference from adjacent tracks isolation and grounding all effect the signal quality further away the greater the issues.
Posted by chj - Sun 05 Apr 2020 17:03
So there's potential for a ryzen 5, DDR5 and PCIe 5 combo in 2021?