HEXUS Forums :: 7 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
Posted by PC-LAD - Tue 02 Oct 2018 16:41
Not bad for the platform but system integration is a more logical solution as 1 drive has <poor> redundancy
Posted by aidanjt - Tue 02 Oct 2018 17:13
That doesn't matter much, it's just a starter home NAS. The important thing is to keep irreplaceable data backed up, so just plug in a USB HDD and you're sound.
Posted by Output - Tue 02 Oct 2018 18:28
As I stated in another thread, I'm personally going to stay away from Synology for the reasons listed there.

I have to say though that a single-bay NAS seems pointless to me, as I see it as being a more expensive External Hard Drive and consider NAS' to consist of at least three bays.
Posted by aidanjt - Tue 02 Oct 2018 19:12
Output
as I see it as being a more expensive External Hard Drive
Expensive external HDD that's attached to a network. Seems fairly NASy to me. Albeit with the CPU being rubbish for all but the most basic NAS tasks.
Posted by Output - Wed 03 Oct 2018 00:32
aidanjt
Expensive external HDD that's attached to a network. Seems fairly NASy to me. Albeit with the CPU being rubbish for all but the most basic NAS tasks.

True, but technically you could simply attach a regular external to many routers and use it in a similarly basic way.

I know a one-bay still IS a NAS in reality, but I just don't personally think it makes sense to get a NAS unless it's three bays or more.
Posted by aidanjt - Wed 03 Oct 2018 06:54
Output
True, but technically you could simply attach a regular external to many routers and use it in a similarly basic way.
Yeah, but then you have to put up with interacting with consumer router software on a much more regular basis. Especially egregious if you need remote access. Truly terrifying.
Posted by Output - Wed 03 Oct 2018 12:07
aidanjt
Yeah, but then you have to put up with interacting with consumer router software on a much more regular basis. Especially egregious if you need remote access. Truly terrifying.

True, I guess it depends purely on individual usage cases.

That doesn't change my personal view of it, but I understand that others have different needs that will mean that it does make sense for them.